New York insurance guide

Product liability insurance for your New York Amazon or Shopify business

A practical state page for your third-party seller business, built around store data, product category, COI requests, and why Amazon or Shopify does not replace your own product liability policy.

42%

average savings

$26

starting monthly

Yes

license listed

Get a free quote Browse states

TLDR

If you're a New York seller, start here.

New York has the highest average product liability premiums in the country, driven by claim frequency and plaintiff-friendly courts.

You should treat New York context as one layer of the quote, not the whole insurance decision.

The current illustrative monthly premium signal for New York is $85, compared with a national baseline of $53.

New York's sales tax context is 4%, which can matter for seller planning even though tax is separate from insurance coverage.

Assureful license information is listed for New York.

State pages should be paired with category pages because skincare, supplements, baby products, electronics, and pet products create different insurance questions.

State comparison

New York context versus the national baseline.

These are planning signals, not a final quote. The real price still depends on product category, monthly sales, claims history, limits, and underwriting review.

Check

New York

National

Seller meaning

Illustrative premium signal

New York

$85/mo

National

$53/mo baseline

New York is currently above the national baseline; product category and sales volume still matter more than the state signal alone.

Sales tax planning context

New York

National

5.1% average signal

Tax context is not insurance coverage, but it can help you think through where your business is based, where you sell, and how your state-specific planning should be documented.

License signal

New York

License listed: 1665658

National

Assureful supports US seller workflows

License data helps confirm regulatory context, but the policy still has to fit products, channels, limits, and buyer wording.

Category overlay

New York

State page plus category page

National

Generic state-only page

The strongest page match combines state, platform, and product niche instead of swapping only the state name.

What changes by state

State-specific does not mean state-only.

Your state matters, but it should be tied to what you sell, the channels you use, and the proof of insurance your buyers or marketplaces ask you to provide.

Business location

Your New York business address can affect licensing, policy administration, taxes, and notices.

Buyer requirements

Amazon, retailers, suppliers, and wholesalers may ask for specific limits, wording, or Additional Insured treatment.

Legal environment

State law, venue, and claim patterns can influence how product claims are handled after a dispute starts.

Product category

The product you sell usually matters more than the state alone. Supplements, skincare, baby products, electronics, and pet products need different review.

Research notes

What this means for your New York seller account.

Selling on Amazon or Shopify does not place your products under Amazon's insurance or a marketplace safety net. If your product injures a customer or damages property, your business can still be pulled into the claim.

You should know that can be strictly liable under New York law for injuries caused by an allegedly defective product offered on its website by a seller.

You should know that amazon moved for summary judgment, arguing that because it did not take title it cannot be held liable for distributing the defective product. The trial court, ...

You should know that fin. News NL 11:New York District Court Rules in Favor of Amazon in Suit Over Defective Product Sold by seller. [Philadelphia ...

You should know that i argue that there is a compelling argument that Amazon is liable for defective third-party goods because it is a merchant seller under § 2-. 314 of the Uniform ...

You should know that amazon can be held liable for defective products that they sell from third parties on its Marketplace and are “Fulfilled by Amazon.

E-commerce business insurance includes general liability and product liability coverage. Our picks for the best companies can help you get ...

A-rated product liability insurance built for Shopify merchants. Connect your store, get priced on real sales data, and download a Certificate of Insurance in ...

You should know that this piece explores some of the unique risks faced by e-commerce stores, such as cyber threats and product liability. It also examines the ...

You should know that liability insurance should be obtained by all sellers on all eCommerce platforms regardless of monthly sales or the platform's insurance requirements. In other ...

Amazon requires all you to obtain product liability insurance after reaching $10,000 in sales in one month via Amazon's US marketplace. Not only ...

Licensing

Assureful license information for New York.

Assureful Insurance Services is listed for New York under license number 1665658. View full license information.

Policy checklist

What a Shopify or Amazon product liability policy should include.

Do not stop at a quote number. The policy should fit the product, the channel, the buyer requirements, and the paperwork your business will actually need.

Product liability

Covered bodily injury and property damage claims tied to products sold through Amazon, Shopify, wholesale, or other supported channels.

Legal defense

Defense costs for covered product claims, including claims that are disputed or never reach trial.

Certificates

Certificate of Insurance support for marketplaces, wholesale buyers, retail partners, suppliers, and Additional Insured requests.

Category fit

Clear treatment of your product category, including ingredients, safety exposure, use case, manufacturing, imports, and claims language.

Channel fit

A policy path that understands you may move between Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, wholesale, and retail buyers.

Case research

Real cases that show seller exposure.

These examples are not legal advice. They show why your own product liability policy matters when you sell on Amazon, Shopify, wholesale, or another channel.

United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit - 2010

In re Ephedra Products Liability Litigation

Why it matters for New York: New York law and supplement-product claims were part of a large product-liability dispute.
What was disputed: Supplement claims involved alleged injury from ephedra-containing products and questions about causation and timing.
Outcome: The appellate decision addressed whether certain claims could proceed under New York law.
Seller takeaway: Supplement sellers should expect review around ingredients, label claims, adverse-event history, testing, and unsupported health-claim risk.

View source

United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit - 2019

Fox v. Amazon.com, Inc.

Why it matters for New York: National marketplace example involving warnings, batteries, and property damage.
What was disputed: A hoverboard bought through Amazon allegedly caused a house fire; the court addressed product-liability and warning theories against Amazon.
Outcome: The Sixth Circuit revived part of the warning-related claim while rejecting other theories.
Seller takeaway: Powered products, electronics, toys, and battery-backed goods can create both injury and property-damage exposure.

View source

Related category intent

You still need product-specific answers.

Skincare

Product liability insurance for skincare brands on Shopify

Supplements

Product liability insurance for supplement brands on Amazon

Skincare

Product liability insurance for skincare brands on Amazon

Cosmetics

Product liability insurance for cosmetics brands on Amazon

Electronics Accessories

Product liability insurance for electronics accessories on Amazon

Baby Products

Product liability insurance for baby products on Amazon

Questions

What to ask before you apply.

Do New York Amazon and Shopify sellers need product liability insurance?+

You may need product liability insurance because Amazon, wholesale buyers, retail partners, suppliers, or lenders can ask you for proof of coverage. Shopify may not require coverage just to run a store, but you still need your own policy once your products create real customer exposure or buyer requirements.

What should a New York eCommerce product liability policy include?+

Look for product liability coverage, general liability where appropriate, legal defense for covered claims, COI support, Additional Insured handling, marketplace-ready proof of insurance, and clear exclusions for the product categories you sell.

Is Assureful licensed for New York sellers?+

Yes. Assureful has state licensing information for New York, and the license details are linked from this page.

Does the buyer's state matter if my business is based in New York?+

Your business location matters for licensing and policy administration, but claims can involve customers, venues, or counterparties outside New York. Make sure your policy supports where you sell and the channels you use.

Can a New York seller use one policy for Amazon and Shopify?+

That is usually the goal if you sell across more than one channel. Your policy should support your business, product category, and proof-of-insurance requirements across Amazon, Shopify, wholesale, and other supported channels.

What is the difference between general liability and product liability?+

General liability is the broader commercial liability policy area. Product liability focuses on covered bodily injury or property damage claims tied to products you sell. If you sell physical products online, product liability and COI support are usually the pieces you need to inspect closely.

What can slow down a quote?+

Unsupported product claims, unclear manufacturing details, recent claims, unresolved recalls, missing supplier information, or unusual buyer wording can add review time before a quote is sent.

Are New York state pages a replacement for category pages?+

No. This page explains local context. Category pages explain product risk. Your questions can be very different if you sell skincare, supplements, electronics, baby products, or pet products, even when your business is based in the same state.

References

Sources used for state case examples.

Review these source links if you want to understand the legal background behind the insurance notes on this page.

01
In re Ephedra Products Liability Litigation
Justia appellate opinion PDF. Used to explain what this can mean for your New York third-party seller business.
02
Fox v. Amazon.com, Inc.
Justia case opinion. Used to explain what this can mean for your New York third-party seller business.
03
NY Ruling On Amazon's Seller Liability Is Good For Plaintiffs
Case-law research result. can be strictly liable under New York law for injuries caused by an allegedly defective product offered on its website by a seller.
04
Amazon May Be Liable As A Retailer For Product Liability ...
Case-law research result. Amazon moved for summary judgment, arguing that because it did not take title it cannot be held liable for distributing the defective product. The trial court, ...
05
Amazon Notches Another Win on Personal Injury Liability ...
Case-law research result. ... New York appellate court upheld a ruling dismissing negligence and breach-of-warranty claims based on injuries allegedly caused by a defective ...
06
State Farm/Amazon: Taking title to goods sold or ...
Case-law research result. Fin. News NL 11:New York District Court Rules in Favor of Amazon in Suit Over Defective Product Sold by seller. [Philadelphia ...
07
AMAZON AS A SELLER OF MARKETPLACE GOODS ...
Case-law research result. I argue that there is a compelling argument that Amazon is liable for defective third-party goods because it is a merchant seller under § 2-. 314 of the Uniform ...
08
Is Amazon Liable For Defective Products?
Case-law research result. Amazon can be held liable for defective products that they sell from third parties on its Marketplace and are “Fulfilled by Amazon.
09
E-Commerce Business Insurance: Best Companies and ...
Case-law research result. E-commerce business insurance includes general liability and product liability coverage. Our picks for the best companies can help you get ...
10
Shopify Store Insurance - Built for Online Sellers
Case-law research result. A-rated product liability insurance built for Shopify merchants. Connect your store, get priced on real sales data, and download a Certificate of Insurance in ...
11
Online Retailers Insurance & Risks | Simply Business
Case-law research result. This piece explores some of the unique risks faced by e-commerce stores, such as cyber threats and product liability. It also examines the ...
12
Insurance for Amazon Sellers
Case-law research result. Liability insurance should be obtained by all sellers on all eCommerce platforms regardless of monthly sales or the platform's insurance requirements. In other ...
13
Product Liability Insurance for Amazon Sellers
Case-law research result. Amazon requires all you to obtain product liability insurance after reaching $10,000 in sales in one month via Amazon's US marketplace. Not only ...
14
Ecommerce Business Insurance
Case-law research result. Get affordable ecommerce business insurance built for Amazon, Etsy & online sellers. Covers product liability and more – start your quote today.

Keep researching

Amazon seller insurance Shopify product liability insurance eCommerce insurance for online sellers Product liability insurance by state Compare insurers

Start now

See if Assureful can cover your New York business.

Connect your store, answer a few questions, and get routed to the right next step for your product category.

Start a free quote